Does out of court settlement require the presence of an attorney?

Do I still need to hire one?

Share |

Answered By: Salladay Law Office

Call now: (208) 333-9600

No an attorney is not required, but it is a good idea to make sure your interests are protected.

Answer Applies to: Idaho - Replied: 6/14/2012

Answered By: Evan Guthrie Law Firm

Call now: (843) 926-3813

Not required but highly recommended.

Answer Applies to: South Carolina - Replied: 6/12/2012

Answered By: Law Office of Melvin Franke

Call now: (636) 271-5300

It depends on the type of case and the type of settlement.

Answer Applies to: Missouri - Replied: 6/11/2012

Answered By: John Russo

Call now: (401) 351-9797

No, it's a good idea though. Insurance companies are skilled at giving you less and making you think you won. Remember the attorney does not get paid unless you settle, and I will assure you of one thing the settlement will be much larger with a lawyer then without one!!!

Answer Applies to: Rhode Island - Replied: 6/9/2012

Answered By: Robinette Legal Group, PLLC

Call now: (304) 594-1800

Some injury claims are so small they may not require legal representation, and in that case you may choose to settle the claim with the insurance company yourself. My best recommendation as a former insurance defense lawyer, though, is if you have suffered serious injuries from a collision, you need to promptly seek advice from an excellent personal injury lawyer. An experienced trial lawyer whose focus is auto injury litigation knows how to preserve all your legal rights, not just some of them, against the attempts of the insurance adjuster and their defense attorneys to defeat or minimize your claim. Chances are this is the first serious accident and recovery you have had to manage, but a lawyer whose focus is auto accident law has handled hundreds of claims for injured people. A skilled advocate will ensure you are not taken advantage of by the complexities of the insurance claim process and will receive the compensation due to you. Retaining an attorney adds credibility to a client's threat to file suit, to pursue a claim to trial, and to negotiate a larger payment. Thus, a client gains more experience, more knowledge, and more negotiating credibility and power in dealing with the insurance industry.

Answer Applies to: West Virginia - Replied: 6/8/2012

Answered By: Darrell B. Reynolds, P.C.

Call now: (404) 636-6616

An attorney can insure that you are treated fairly in a settlement and that you are receiving what you should receive.

Answer Applies to: Georgia - Replied: 6/8/2012

Answered By: Lombardi Law Firm

Call now: (515) 222-1110

No but it's a good idea to have a lawyer so you are able to enforce the settlement by properly memorializing the terms of settlement.

Answer Applies to: Iowa - Replied: 6/8/2012

Answered By: Law Offices of David W. Hibbert

Call now: (770) 414-8055

No , an out of court settlement does not require an attorney. However, when faced with professionals trained in minimizing your recovery it is often wiser to get advice from a skilled negotiator that has YOUR rights and interest protected not the insurance company.

Answer Applies to: Georgia - Replied: 6/8/2012

Answered By: The Lucky Law Firm, PLC

Call now: (225) 387-5656

If you wish to understand the legal ramifications of the settlement, it is best to have an attorney. However, there is no requirement that an attorney be present. Some settlements may require the presence of a notary public, but not an attorney per se.

Answer Applies to: Louisiana - Replied: 6/7/2012

Answered By: James M. Osak, P.C.

Call now: (248) 515-9807

NO. You can always settle without an attorney. However . . . don't cry later on when you get shortchanged. The reason you need a lawyer is: 1) to view your legal options; and 2) to keep the other side "honest."

Answer Applies to: Michigan - Replied: 6/7/2012

Answered By: Mike Yeksavich

Call now: (918) 592-6050

People can settle cases without an attorney but without an attorney the settlement might not be appropriate.

Answer Applies to: Oklahoma - Replied: 6/7/2012

Answered By: Law Office of Mark J. Leonardo

Call now: (310) 456-7373

No you do not need an attorney if you settle out of court, but the chances of you getting maximum value without one are remote. If an insurance company is involved, they will certainly take advantage of that fact and pay you as little as possible.

Answer Applies to: California - Replied: 6/7/2012

Answered By: Conway Law Pllc.

Call now: (800) 482-5297

If you want get full and fair compensation, You better get a Great Lawyer. Injuries and all other damages must be documented or the insurance company will not consider them.

Answer Applies to: Virginia - Replied: 6/7/2012

Answered By: Timothy Jones, Attorney at Law

Call now: (503) 225-0777

No. It depends on the complexity of your case.

Answer Applies to: Oregon - Replied: 6/7/2012

Answered By: Andrew T. Velonis, P.C.

Call now: (315) 579-3108

Unless this is a small claims action for a few hundred bucks, then no you can't handle a claim on your own and yes you do need an attorney. There are many rules, procedures, exceptions, requirements etc. and it is very easy to get tripped up. The old saying is: "He who acts as his own lawyer has a fool for a client". You have a right to represent yourself, just as I have a right to perform dentistry on myself, but that would be a really bad idea. Seriously, this is a tricky business and there is no room for do-it-yourselfers. If you retain a lawyer you will be much more likely to get the right result.

Answer Applies to: New York - Replied: 6/7/2012

Answered By: R. D. Kelly Law Firm, P.L.L.C.

Call now: (206) 623-3702

You have a legal right to represent yourself. I believe your chances of getting what you want improve when you retain a good attorney.

Answer Applies to: Washington - Replied: 6/7/2012

Answered By: Law Office of Ronald G. Draper

Call now: (312) 360-9411

Yes. Insurance companies either will not act in good faith with you or they will take advantage of you. Hire a lawyer.

Answer Applies to: Illinois - Replied: 6/7/2012

Answered By: Holzer Edwards

Call now: (208) 386-9119

NO. But that means that you will not get any legal advice about what the settlement papers means or the terms of the settlement.

Answer Applies to: Idaho - Replied: 6/7/2012

Answered By: Ricks & Associates

Call now: (909) 890-1090

Not technically but you should have an attorney review and/or prepare the settlement documents.

Answer Applies to: California - Replied: 6/7/2012

Answered By: Atterbury, Kammer & Haag

Call now: (608) 821-4600

No, unless the settlement is on behalf of a minor or other person who is in need of a guardian ad litem.

Answer Applies to: Wisconsin - Replied: 6/7/2012

Answered By: The Law Office of Stephen R. Chesley, LLC

Call now: (718) 569-8738

A lawyer is not needed if there is a settlement. However I suggest you speak to an attorney to make sure you obtain the maximum recovery under the circumstances. You should contact an attorney to discuss your matter further.

Answer Applies to: New York - Replied: 6/7/2012

Answered By: Dunnings Law Firm

Call now: (517) 487-8222

You might be better off consulting with one to determine whether the settlement amount is fair.

Answer Applies to: Michigan - Replied: 6/7/2012

Answered By: Lapin Law Offices

Call now: (402) 421-8033

You are not required to have an attorney to settle a case. However, it may be your advantage to hire an attorney to determine whether a settlement is fair or if you might be entitled to more money.

Answer Applies to: Nebraska - Replied: 6/7/2012

Answered By: Dwyer, Black & Lyle, LLP

Call now: (716) 373-1920

Typically no but, you should have something in writing or do it on the record. The only the attorney would help you with is the value and terms of the settlement, which are critical. Good luck.

Answer Applies to: New York - Replied: 6/7/2012

Answered By: Bernard Huff, Attorney/Mediator

Call now: (317) 542-8540

You should at least consult with a personal injury lawyer, especially, if your injuries and/or damages are substantial.

Answer Applies to: Indiana - Replied: 6/7/2012

Answered By: Joel H. Schwartz, P.C.

Call now: (617) 742-1170

You are free to negotiate with an insurance company on your own, but I would not suggest this. Insurance companies will typically take advantage of those not represented. It is always best to at least seek a free consultation from an experienced personal injury attorney in your area.

Answer Applies to: Massachusetts - Replied: 6/7/2012

Answered By: Koning & Jilek, P.C.

Call now: (269) 343-1500

You should never settle a case without assistance of a lawyer.

Answer Applies to: Michigan - Replied: 6/7/2012

Answered By: Law Offices of Mark L. Smith

Call now: (401) 272-1432

No attorney is required if you have reached an agreement. The insurance company will send you a release to sign. Anything which occurs after the signing of a release which is related to the accident will be your problem.

Answer Applies to: Rhode Island - Replied: 6/7/2012

Answered By: Pearson, Butler, & Carson, PLLC

Call now: (801) 495-4104

No it does not. However, its always better to have an attorney to ensure your rights are being protected.

Answer Applies to: Utah - Replied: 6/6/2012

Answered By: Musilli Brennan Associates PLLC

Call now: (586) 778-0900

You should not make a final agreement until you have it at least reviewed by an attorney.

Answer Applies to: Michigan - Replied: 6/6/2012

Answered By: Adler Law Group, LLC

Call now: (860) 282-8686

No. But you likely won't receive a proper one without good attorney to create the circumstances for an appropriate settlement and to threaten suit.

Answer Applies to: Connecticut - Replied: 6/6/2012

Answered By: The Law Firm of Shawn M. Murray

Call now: (985) 624-9393

No, but you would be well advised to do so. An experienced personal injury attorney will surely recover more money for you, after their fee, than you will be able to recover for yourself.

Answer Applies to: Louisiana - Replied: 6/6/2012

Answered By: David F. Stoddard

Call now: (864) 375-0000

If you are settling a case for a minor, you have to have an attorney. Otherwise, you do not.

Answer Applies to: South Carolina - Replied: 6/6/2012

Answered By: Alvin Lundgren

Call now: (801) 876-4422

You do not need an attorney to settle a personal injury case. However, generally an attorney can help you get a better settlement than without an attorney even considering attorney fees.

Answer Applies to: Utah - Replied: 6/6/2012

Answered By: Rags Beals Seigler Patterson & Gray

Call now: (706) 216-1272

No. But you should have a written signed agreement.

Answer Applies to: Georgia - Replied: 6/6/2012

Answered By: Paris Blank LLP

Call now: (804) 355-0691

Usually not, but if a minor is involved or a case involving death by wrongful act, you will need court approval.

Answer Applies to: Virginia - Replied: 6/6/2012

Answered By: Law Office of Russell D. Gray, PC

Call now: (801) 305-4851

At attorney could help you make sure your settlement is enough and that your case is ready to settle. If you have any questions about either of these issues, you should consult an attorney.

Answer Applies to: Utah - Replied: 6/6/2012

Answered By: The Smalley Law Firm, LLC

Call now: (913) 601-3549

I suggest you consult with an attorney to ensure that you are fairly compensated.

Answer Applies to: Kansas - Replied: 6/6/2012

Answered By: Coulter's Law

Call now: (732) 769-2445

No, but you would be foolish to sign something without one.

Answer Applies to: New Jersey - Replied: 6/6/2012

Answered By: Rita Skuratovsky

Call now: (818) 401-4717

If you are simply settling out of court, no. But you probably want to have the settlement terms in writing. That can be quite tricky and may require assistance of counsel.

Answer Applies to: California - Replied: 6/6/2012

Answered By: Kelaher Law Offices, P.A.

Call now: (407) 841-7698

No, it does not but sign any release only after reading it very carefully.

Answer Applies to: Florida - Replied: 6/6/2012

Answered By: Ross Law L.L.C.

Call now: (503) 224-1658

Most Personal Injury attorneys work on a contingency basis. That means that they do not get paid unless you recover for your injuries. Many Attorneys will also advance some, or all, of the litigation costs. This means that you do not have to hire an attorney. In most cases, insurance companies will give an attorney a much better offer to settle the case than to a person handling their own claim. Lastly, in Oregon Attorneys can collect their fees from the defendant (the person that injured you) in certain circumstances involving cases under $10,000.00. This means that you can collect the full award (settlement amount or judgment) and the Attorney gets paid by the other side.

Answer Applies to: Oregon - Replied: 6/6/2012

Answered By: Bruce Plesser

Call now: (727) 421-9784

No but you'll get screwed.

Answer Applies to: Florida - Replied: 6/6/2012

Answered By: Rogoway Green, LLP

Call now: (503) 935-5450

No, but I would hesitate ever going forward with a settlement without at least consulting with an attorney. If you are negotiating with an insurance company, you can be sure they are, at the very least, trying to take advantage of you and the fact that you are not represented.

Answer Applies to: Oregon - Replied: 6/6/2012

Answered By: Broad Law Firm, LLC

Call now: (317) 566-2134

While it is not necessary to have an attorney to reach an out-of-court settlement, it is usually wise to hire one to make sure the settlement you are getting is fair and just.

Answer Applies to: Indiana - Replied: 6/6/2012

Answered By: Frank Law Group, P.C.

Call now: (530) 887-8585

If you want to ensure adequate compensation yes, but if you have already agreed on a number, no. Carrier will require that you execute a release which will outline all the terms.

Answer Applies to: California - Replied: 6/6/2012

Answered By: Gebler & Weiss, P.C.

Call now: (818) 876-9552

You can settle by yourself but not a good idea because they usually will not pay you a fair amount.

Answer Applies to: California - Replied: 6/6/2012

Answered By: Shaw Law Firm

Call now: (425) 214-4946

No, but it wouldn't hurt to talk to one to make sure the offer you are getting is adequate.

Answer Applies to: Washington - Replied: 6/6/2012

Answered By: Law Offices of Maxwell Charles Livingston

Call now: (262) 789-2741

Not necessarily, but it would be highly recommended (to hedge risk).

Answer Applies to: Wisconsin - Replied: 6/6/2012

Disclaimer: The responses above do not form an attorney-client relationship. These answers may or may not apply to you and should not be relied upon as legal advice. LawQA does not make any representation as to the expertise or qualifications of this attorney. These attorneys may or may not be admitted to state bar of your state.

More Questions on Personal Injury


Speak with an Attorney Today

Ask a Local Attorney

Ask Questions

Ask a local attorney a question for FREE.

Free Answers

FREE answer from a local attorney.

100% Anonymous

Your email is only used to send answers to you.